Use Code WELCOME10 To Save 10% Now
Close
UNLOCK SAVINGS
Sign up for our monthly newsletter to receive discount codes and see all the latest specials.
Go
Search
Close menu
Menu
Search
Log in
Create account
0
Cart
Added to Cart
You have
items in your cart
You have
1
item in your cart
Total
Check Out
Continue Shopping
Home Decor Gifts
All Home Decor Gifts
Wreaths and Floral Gifts
Decorative Lanterns
Personalized Picture Frames
All Personalized Picture Frames
Personalized Family Picture Frames
Celebration Personalized Photo Frames
Seasonal Custom Photo Frames
Custom Canvas Wall Art And Prints
Pillows and Pillow Cases
All Pillows and Pillow Cases
Personalized Family Throw Pillows
Seasonal Throw Pillows
Pet Throw Pillows
Unique Kitchen Gifts
All Unique Kitchen Gifts
Personalized Cutting Boards
Coffee Mugs and Bottle Gifts
Decorative Kitchen Accents
Christmas & Holiday Decor Gifts
All Christmas Gift Ideas
Christmas Holiday Home Decor
Christmas Decorations And Figurines
Holiday Ornaments
Fall Home Decor
Cabin Decor
Wedding Gifts
All Wedding Gifts
Bridesmaid Gifts
Groomsmen Gifts
Gifts For The Couple
Personalized Decanters & Flasks
Wedding Party Favors
Wedding Signs
Occasions
Valentines Day Gifts
Birthday/Congrats Gifts
Housewarming Gifts
Retirement Gifts
Sympathy and Memorial Gifts
Religious Gifts
Graduation Gifts
Recipient
Pet Gifts
Dog Door Toppers
Dog Planter Boxes
Dog Leash Holders
Dog Weathervanes
Gifts For Him
Gifts For Her
Gifts for Children
Grandpa Gifts
Grandmother Gifts
Baby Gifts
Teacher Gift Ideas
Category
Farmhouse Decor
Primitive Home Decor
Personalized Keepsakes
Clothing
All Occasion Custom Picture Frames
Stylish Bags
Coffee Mugs and Bottle Gifts
Engraved Humidors And Cigar Accessories
Custom Canvas Wall Art And Prints
Wreaths and Floral Decor Gifts
Enamelware
Seasonal Gifts
Fall Home Decor
Spring Home Decor Gifts
Gardening Gifts
All Christmas Gift Ideas
Reviews
Search
Search
Close menu
Home Decor Gifts
All Home Decor Gifts
Wreaths and Floral Gifts
Decorative Lanterns
Personalized Picture Frames
All Personalized Picture Frames
Personalized Family Picture Frames
Celebration Personalized Photo Frames
Seasonal Custom Photo Frames
Custom Canvas Wall Art And Prints
Pillows and Pillow Cases
All Pillows and Pillow Cases
Personalized Family Throw Pillows
Seasonal Throw Pillows
Pet Throw Pillows
Unique Kitchen Gifts
All Unique Kitchen Gifts
Personalized Cutting Boards
Coffee Mugs and Bottle Gifts
Decorative Kitchen Accents
Christmas & Holiday Decor Gifts
All Christmas Gift Ideas
Christmas Holiday Home Decor
Christmas Decorations And Figurines
Holiday Ornaments
Fall Home Decor
Cabin Decor
Wedding Gifts
All Wedding Gifts
Bridesmaid Gifts
Groomsmen Gifts
Gifts For The Couple
Personalized Decanters & Flasks
Wedding Party Favors
Wedding Signs
Occasions
Valentines Day Gifts
Birthday/Congrats Gifts
Housewarming Gifts
Retirement Gifts
Sympathy and Memorial Gifts
Religious Gifts
Graduation Gifts
Recipient
Pet Gifts
Dog Door Toppers
Dog Planter Boxes
Dog Leash Holders
Dog Weathervanes
Gifts For Him
Gifts For Her
Gifts for Children
Grandpa Gifts
Grandmother Gifts
Baby Gifts
Teacher Gift Ideas
Category
Farmhouse Decor
Primitive Home Decor
Personalized Keepsakes
Clothing
All Occasion Custom Picture Frames
Stylish Bags
Coffee Mugs and Bottle Gifts
Engraved Humidors And Cigar Accessories
Custom Canvas Wall Art And Prints
Wreaths and Floral Decor Gifts
Enamelware
Seasonal Gifts
Fall Home Decor
Spring Home Decor Gifts
Gardening Gifts
All Christmas Gift Ideas
Reviews
Search
Log in
Create account
Home
›
Personalized Keepsakes
Personalized Keepsakes
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Grid view
List view
Shugar Plums Gift Store offers a variety of personalized keepsakes for that momentous occasion. Perfect wedding and baby keepsakes, 50th anniversary gift ideas, customized crosses,
confirmation and baptism gifts.
Collection Menu
Personalized Team Coach Or Teacher Keepsake Signature Frame
$44.99
Unit price
/
per
Custom Quinceanera Signature Frame
$47.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized High Polish Silver Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box
$36.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized High Polish Gold Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box
$38.95
$41.99
Unit price
/
per
Childrens Custom Name Wooden Baptism Cross - Blue
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Wooden Children's Baptism Cross - Pink
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Memorial Remembering A Loved One Throw Pillow 18"
$21.95
$31.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized First Communion Frame
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
First Communion Custom Frame For Her
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
First Communion Photo Frame For Him
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
First Communion Custom Photo Frame
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
Blue
Pink
Personalized Secret Agent Hidden Note Cufflinks Gift Set
$39.95
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Military Beer Mug Steins - All Branches
$28.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Rawhide Passport Holder
$21.99
Unit price
/
per
Gold
Silver
Blind
Personalized Memorial Frame - In Memory 8" x 10"
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Passport Holder - Modern Black
$21.99
Unit price
/
per
Gold
Silver
Blind
Personalized Memorial Picture Frame - Memorial Keepsakes
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Memorial Frame - In Our Hearts 8" x 10"
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Memorial Picture Frame - Forever
$24.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Babys Monogram Vine 18" x 18" Canvas
$48.99
$65.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Black Leather Business Card Holder Gift For Him
$15.99
Unit price
/
per
Personalized Silver Plated Heart Shaped Compact Mirror
$19.95
Unit price
/
per
1
review
Personalized Leather Large Bible Cover 11” L x 8” W x 2.25" H
$40.99
$45.99
Unit price
/
per
Custom Leather Small Bible Cover 9.5” L x 7” W x 2.25" H
$36.99
$43.99
Unit price
/
per