Use Code Fathers10 To Save 10% Now
Close

UNLOCK SAVINGS

Sign up for our monthly newsletter to receive discount codes and see all the latest specials.

0 Cart
Added to Cart
    You have items in your cart
    You have 1 item in your cart
      Total
      Check Out Continue Shopping

      Personalized Keepsakes

      Shugar Plums Gift Store offers a variety of personalized keepsakes for that momentous occasion. Perfect wedding and baby keepsakes, 50th anniversary gift ideas, customized crosses, confirmation and baptism gifts.
      Collection Menu
      Personalized Team Coach Or Teacher Keepsake Signature Frame Personalized Team Coach Or Teacher Keepsake Signature Frame
      Personalized Team Coach Or Teacher Keepsake Signature Frame
      $44.99
      Custom Quinceanera Signature Frame Custom Quinceanera Signature Frame
      Custom Quinceanera Signature Frame
      $47.99
      Personalized High Polish Silver Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box Personalized High Polish Silver Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box
      Personalized High Polish Silver Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box
      $36.99
      Personalized High Polish Gold Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box Personalized High Polish Gold Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box
      Personalized High Polish Gold Keepsake Compass With Wooden Box
      $38.95 $41.99
      Childrens Custom Name Wooden Baptism Cross - Blue
      Childrens Custom Name Wooden Baptism Cross - Blue
      $24.99
      Personalized Wooden Children's Baptism Cross - Pink
      Personalized Wooden Children's Baptism Cross - Pink
      $24.99
      Personalized Memorial Remembering A Loved One Throw Pillow 18"
      Personalized Memorial Remembering A Loved One Throw Pillow 18"
      $21.95 $31.99
      Personalized First Communion Frame
      Personalized First Communion Frame
      $24.99
      First Communion Custom Frame For Her
      First Communion Custom Frame For Her
      $24.99
      First Communion Photo Frame For Him
      First Communion Photo Frame For Him
      $24.99
      First Communion Custom Photo Frame First Communion Custom Photo Frame
      First Communion Custom Photo Frame
      $24.99
      Personalized Secret Agent Hidden Note Cufflinks Gift Set
      Personalized Secret Agent Hidden Note Cufflinks Gift Set
      $39.95
      Personalized Military Beer Mug Steins - All Branches Personalized Military Beer Mug Steins - All Branches
      Personalized Military Beer Mug Steins - All Branches
      $28.99
      Personalized Rawhide Passport Holder Personalized Rawhide Passport Holder
      Personalized Rawhide Passport Holder
      $21.99
      Personalized Memorial Frame - In Memory 8" x 10"
      Personalized Memorial Frame - In Memory 8" x 10"
      $24.99
      Personalized Passport Holder - Modern Black Personalized Passport Holder - Modern Black
      Personalized Passport Holder - Modern Black
      $21.99
      Personalized Memorial Picture Frame - Memorial Keepsakes
      Personalized Memorial Picture Frame - Memorial Keepsakes
      $24.99
      Personalized Memorial Frame - In Our Hearts 8" x 10"
      Personalized Memorial Frame - In Our Hearts 8" x 10"
      $24.99
      Personalized Memorial Picture Frame - Forever
      Personalized Memorial Picture Frame - Forever
      $24.99
      Personalized Babys Monogram Vine 18" x 18" Canvas Personalized Babys Monogram Vine 18" x 18" Canvas
      Personalized Babys Monogram Vine 18" x 18" Canvas
      $48.99 $65.99
      Personalized Black Leather Business Card Holder Gift For Him
      Personalized Black Leather Business Card Holder Gift For Him
      $15.99
      Personalized Silver Plated Heart Shaped Compact Mirror
      Personalized Silver Plated Heart Shaped Compact Mirror
      $19.95
      1 review
      Personalized Leather Large Bible Cover 11” L x 8” W x 2.25" H Personalized Leather Large Bible Cover 11” L x 8” W x 2.25" H
      Personalized Leather Large Bible Cover 11” L x 8” W x 2.25" H
      $40.99 $45.99
      Custom Leather Small Bible Cover 9.5” L x 7” W x 2.25" H Custom Leather Small Bible Cover 9.5” L x 7” W x 2.25" H
      Custom Leather Small Bible Cover 9.5” L x 7” W x 2.25" H
      $36.99 $43.99